Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Swimming in Chlorinated Water Causes Bladder Cancer (Not)

Here is a great example of what can happen when a press release is published as news.

Referring to a recent paper, several outlets came out with headlines such as “Swimming too often in chlorinated water 'could increase risk of developing bladder cancer', claim scientists” and “Swimming too often in chlorinated water 'ups bladder cancer risk.'” The paper, entitled “Socioeconomic status and exposure to disinfection by-products in drinking water in Spain,” is available in full text on line.

The researchers looked at data from a study of people in various regions of Spain. The 1271 subjects in the study had served as controls in a different study that was done 10 years ago. They concluded that those in higher socioeconomic groups drank less tap water but took longer showers and used swimming pools more often. It seems that by-products of chlorination, trihalomethanes (THM), have been linked to an increased incidence of bladder cancer. And THM can be absorbed through the skin, making a link of bladder cancer with swimming plausible.

Here is the catch and it can only be discovered by reading the full text of the paper. Participation in swimming was characterized as follows:

“swimming pool attendance, [was recorded] as a dichotomous variable: attending a swimming pool once or more than once per year contrasted with never (or less than once per year)”

In other words, a subject was asked whether he swam in a pool during a year. If he said “Yes,” he was listed as a swimmer, whether he swam once a year or once a day.

You need not be a scientist or a statistician to see the fallacy of this purported association of swimming and bladder cancer.

By the way, as far as I can tell, none of the 1271 subjects actually developed bladder cancer. The research wasn’t designed to look at that. It was taking a post hoc look at water usage by a group of people who were the subjects of a different research hypothesis.

Also, an author of the paper conceded in the press release that the risk of contracting bladder cancer from swimming was “small.”

Bottom line. Swimmers, please relax and ignore this overblown drivel.

And if you are worried about getting bladder cancer from drinking chlorinated water, here are two interesting points. One, a study from the New England Journal of Medicine a few years ago reported that drinking a lot of fluid decreases the risk of bladder cancer. Two, the incidence of bladder cancer has been remarkably stable over the last 30 years.


Vickie said...

Thank goodness...

Anonymous said...

If swimming in chlorinated pool water does not pose any serious health risk, why is it that the EPA has a computer program called SwimModel3.0 that calculates the potential for a swimmer to develop serious illness based on their age, size, and frequency of exposure to chlorine and its byproducts as a result of competitive swimming?

Skeptical Scalpel said...

I agree that levels of chlorine in swimming pools should be monitored. The fact that the EPA suggests monitoring levels of chemicals does not automatically mean that said chemicals are harmful when they are used properly. Too much ingestion of anything, even water, can cause significant problems. [Marathon runners have died from over-hydration. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_intoxication]

Please show me a study that conclusively proves that swimmers have a higher incidence of bladder cancer.

Anonymous said...

Well, I was diagnosed with bladder cancer and had no risk factors--smoking, drinking, long exposure to dyes, so on. But I have been swimming in chlorinated pools for the past 45 years, nearly on a daily basis. I'm not sure that caused it but studies other than the Barcelona one has shown a link between the cleaning agents (chlorine and bromine) interacting with organic material (sweat, hair, skin, urine in the pool) to trigger genotoxicity (or some thing) that increases certain markers seven-fold. So, that may be the actual reason than social class (as the obviously flawed Barcelona study implied).

Skeptical Scalpel said...

Anon, thanks for commenting. The American Cancer Society has published a list of risk factors for bladder cancer (http://www.cancer.org/cancer/bladdercancer/detailedguide/bladder-cancer-risk-factors). Swimming in chlorinated pools is not one of them.

It also notes that people with no risk factors can develop bladder cancer.

Unknown said...

Shill written article , i have as well as my neighbor, bladder cancer . We live next to a municipal well that has a very aggressive chlorine treatment . tractor trailers loaded with bags of chlorine. Shower smells like a pool . Installed reverse osmosis filters . I read an american article where they admit that 30% of bladder cancer cases are due to over chlorinization ( probably 60%) you do yourself and the public a GREAT disservice.Shill

Skeptical Scalpel said...

Shill for what? Do you think the makers of swimming pool chemicals hired me to write this? They didn't.

I'm sorry you and your neighbor have bladder cancer. However, if you read the post, it was not about over-chlorination. It was about an attempt to link swimming with bladder cancer. I was merely pointing out that the "research" described in the paper failed to prove that.

Anonymous said...

Really? They could have checked swimmers. We'd be a great study to prove that wrong. I've seen tons of them, look at the Olympic swimmers. That would be fairly easy to check, and who has cancer in the family.

Skeptical Scalpel said...

As far as I know, no one has done such a study because there has not been any suspicion that competitive swimmers are getting bladder cancer at a rate higher than any other group.

Post a Comment